StagingBench
Head-to-head · same test room

TINTY vs Collov AI

Both tools staged the same empty room with default settings; only the first output counts. Verdict first, then every number we have.

Last updated · prices checked 19 October 2026

Partial results. As of 21 October 2026 we have scored room 01 of 10 for 8 tools (tested 19 October 2026), plus a few extra rooms for some. The other 12 of the 20 tools we list are not tested yet. No final ranking. How we test

Verdict

Collov AI kept the room closer to the original on room 01: architecture drift 11.0 vs 18.1 (lower is better). On published prices Collov AI is cheaper per staged photo: $0.45 vs $2.25 on the cheapest paid option.

Pick TINTY if…
  • you want to try it before creating an account (Yes (previews)).
Pick Collov AI if…
  • walls, windows and doors must stay as they are: lower room 01 drift (11.0 vs 18.1).
  • the delivered photo must keep your exact camera frame: it passed our framing check; TINTY failed it (only 89.1% of the original frame visible).
  • speed matters: room 01 came back in 18.6 s vs about 30 s.
  • cost per photo decides it: $0.45 vs $2.25 on the cheapest paid option (Standard (monthly), $27/month).
  • you need furniture removal (declutter), restyling a furnished room, day-to-dusk, sky replacement, virtual renovation (wall and floor recolor), 360 or video output, an API, a "virtually staged" disclaimer option and a stated commercial-use licence: listed on Collov AI's pages, not listed or not verified for TINTY.

Built from the numbers below, not a paid placement. This is not a final ranking.

TINTY

AI · tinty.ai

Full TINTY page →

Collov AI

AI · collov.ai

Full Collov AI page →

TINTY vs Collov AI, side by side
Room rows are our own tests; prices, plans and features from public pages checked 2026-10-19. ✓ yes · ✕ no · ? not verified.
Partial · 1 of 10 rooms
MetricTINTYCollov AI
TypeAIAI
Tested by StagingBenchRoom 01 (1 of 10)Room 01 plus 4 more rooms (5 of 10)
Room 01 architecture drift (lower = better)18.111.0
Room 01 framingFailPass
Room 01 time to result~30 s18.6 s
Watermark on our free outputYes (tiled)Yes (logo)
Free output size (original 1280x960)1248x8321200x896
Editor realism, room 01 (1-5)4.04.2
Cheapest paid optionBase, $9/monthStandard (monthly), $27/month
Price per photo, cheapest option$2.25$0.45
Next tierStandard ($39/mo, 20 photos) · $1.95/photoAdvanced ($59/mo, 150 credits; $49/mo yearly) · $0.39/photo
Free tier (vendor page)6 previews per photo, 20 a month, plus 3 finished photos once (light watermark); 3 previews/day without an account5 free trial images with watermark
Try without an accountYes (previews)No
TurnaroundPreviews in about 30 s10-second turnaround (vendor claim)
Refund policy (vendor)30-day money-back guarantee on the first payment; renewals non-refundableFull refund within 7 days if fewer than 10 photos were uploaded
Redo / revisions (vendor)Failed renders return to your balanceUnlimited regeneration (4 renders per version)
Max resolution (vendor)2K (about 2,500 px long side)not stated
Declutter / remove furniture✕✓
Empty-room staging✓✓
Restyle a furnished room✕✓
Day to dusk?✓
Sky replacement?✓
Renovation / wall & floor recolor?✓
360 or video?✓
API?✓
"Virtually staged" disclaimer option?✓
Commercial-use licence stated?✓

Room 01: original vs staged

Same empty open-plan room, default settings, first output only. Each image shows the original next to the aligned output.

TINTY · room 01

Room 01 original vs TINTY staged output
Compare image · full output

Collov AI · room 01

Room 01 original vs Collov AI staged output
Compare image · full output

What we noted

TINTY

Room 01: Framing fails: the default crop frame returns a 3:2 image, so about 54 px are cut from the top and from the bottom (11% of the frame). Inside the visible area the architecture matches the original closely. Time is approximate (at most about 30 s).

Editor notes: Living zone staged; suits open plan. Believable sizes; the sideboard is pushed against the left door frame. No warped objects; a black chair is cut off at the right edge and the 3:2 crop loses the top and bottom.

Pricing notes: Listing pack $29 once for 10 photos ($2.90). TINTY Studio (human-finished): $10/photo, 2-24 h. Stages empty rooms only; no kitchens, bathrooms or exteriors.

Sources: tinty.ai/pricing (checked 2026-10-19)

Collov AI

Room 01: Lowest architecture drift on room 01 and kept the frame. Removed the chair that was already in the room (allowed: it is furniture). Output is slightly smaller than the original (1200x896 vs 1280x960).

Editor notes: Living zone staged and kitchen untouched, which suits an open-plan room. Sofa, rug and chairs are sized right and leave the kitchen walkway clear. No melted or floating items; the large central collov.ai logo is the main blemish.

Pricing notes: Yearly billing: $0.32/photo (Standard) and $0.33 (Advanced). Credits reset monthly. 'High-resolution downloads' (no pixel size given); our free outputs were about 1.1 MP. $19/mo if billed yearly ($228).

Sources: collov.ai/pricing (checked 2026-10-19); collov.ai/affiliate (checked 2026-10-19)

Architecture drift runs from 0 to 100, lower is better (how much walls, windows and doors changed after aligning the output to the original). Differences of about 3 points or less are within measurement noise. Framing fails if the tool cropped, zoomed, shifted or rotated the photo beyond our thresholds. Editor realism ratings are one person's 1-5 ratings, not blind. Details: methodology. Partial results: 1 of 10 rooms scored for most tools (Collov AI also has rooms 02-05, Pedra rooms 02-06 and Roomagen room 02. The leaderboard still compares room 01 only.). Prices from vendors' public pages, checked 19 October 2026; EUR converted at the ECB rate (1.1253, 2026-10-16). Nobody paid for a placement, and affiliate links never change the order.

Related pages